Economic history teaches valuable lessons about inflection points and the
wisdom of acting on them. They occur when many of the old rules and assumptions
no longer apply. A few notable examples in the past century include:
- Henry Ford's assembly line that opened an age of mass industrial production.
- Aviation, which opened the possibilities of global business connections.
- The transistor, which paved the way for a computer age.
- And of course, computer- to- computer communication, which led to the Internet
and World Wide Web.
Could supply chain management be on the brink of such an inflection point?
Certainly, the ground rules are changing. Geopolitical uncertainty, disruptive
technologies, new business models, emerging economies, new consumer expectations,
and demographic shifts are all occurring at breakneck speed. At the same time,
two remarkable trends - fast-evolving networking technologies, and the exploding
growth of trade across national borders - continue to flourish.
These trends are taking us into a world of synchronized commerce - a world
where the flows of goods, information and funds are converging. How might new
ground rules and the possibilities of synchronized commerce cause us to rethink
some long-held assumptions about global supply chains? To help answer that question,
UPS recently decided to pull together many of the world's best thinkers
on the global economy and supply chain to examine it, and to learn from each
other.
Together with Harvard Business School Publishing, UPS set out to map the developing
new world of synchronized commerce in a recent summit called "Longitudes
04." Attendees heard the global economy perspectives of Robert
Rubin, former Secretary of the Treasury; Carla Hills, former U.S. trade representative;
and Frederik Willem de Klerk, former president of South Africa and Nobel Peace
Prize recipient. Organizers also assembled a select group of seasoned supply
chain experts who represent major global corporations and academia.
The New York conference proved so insightful, UPS has decided to continue the
global economy summits twice a year in different regions of the world through
2007 to build on the dialogue began in New York.
What have we learned so far?
The emerging consensus is that commerce - increasingly practiced on a global
scale - will only become more complex in the coming years. And as it does,
a compelling need arises to simplify and synchronize business processes. In
fact, the Longitudes counselors advised C-level and supply chain executives
that they could stake out great advantage ahead if they closely aligned their
supply chain strategies to five key business challenges, including:
- Growing by reaching new markets
- Improving customer service
- Differentiating from competitors
- Improving cash position
- And, enhancing productivity
The Longitudes experts agreed, by effectively synchronizing the flows of goods
and information, the supply chain can profoundly influence each of these priorities.
Reaching new markets
Longitudes speaker Bob Moffat, senior vice president of integrated supply chain
for IBM, pointed out that supply chains can drive top as well as bottom-line
growth. And a company doesn't have to be a multibillion dollar corporation
to gain this advantage.
Genuine Guide Gear (G3) of Vancouver is a specialized maker of high-end backcountry
ski equipment. The company wanted to expand its sales to specialty shops across
the border in the U.S. by using an established supply chain. G3 relied on an
outsourcing partner to create a logistics solution that would get its equipment
to American customers faster.
Today, the logistics firm assembles all U.S.-bound shipments at its distribution
center in Canada. It then clears these multiple orders as a single shipment
through customs. This consolidation saves time, paperwork and transportation
costs. Once the consolidated shipment arrives at its delivery company's
warehouse in the U.S., the shipment is separated out into individual orders
and delivered to retailers and ski resorts. G3 gets an instant U.S. presence
by using an established supply chain. And the best news is the partnership is
doubling top-line sales revenue almost every year.
Exploring the customer mindset
Whether it's serving new customers in new markets or existing customers,
the essential foundation of supply chain management lies in a deep understanding
of customer needs, believes Hau Lee, professor of operations, information and
technology at The Stanford University graduate school of business.
"You really have to go into the mindset of your customers to truly understand
what they want," he said. Lee relayed a story told by former basketball
star and entrepreneur, Magic Johnson, about an inner city theater owned by Johnson
that ran out of food on its opening night. Despite the theater manager's
30 years of experience, he didn't completely understand his immediate
customers' needs, and consequently, did not accurately forecast demand.
He didn't realize that in the inner city, people don't have enough
money to go to a movie and dinner. Instead, they eat dinner at the movie theater,
consuming far more hot dogs than years of experience at suburban movie theaters
would suggest.
The point is that customer needs ultimately drive demand. And demand, in turn,
is the key driver of the overall supply chain. Every organization needs to examine
its customers' needs. Not surprisingly, today's airports are under
a lot of pressure to enhance customer satisfaction. The Singapore Airport is
one of the best. It's been recognized as one of the world's most
efficient at getting people on to their final, local destinations.
Many airports measure how fast they can get a passenger out of the plane, through
baggage pick-up, through customs, and outside the terminal. The Singapore Airport
goes one step further. It measures how fast a passenger can get a taxi. It's
that a crucial detail,
yet, it was a performance measure no one owned. Airports cared about what went
on inside the airport; the taxi drivers cared about the congestion on the road.
But if you're the traveler, what good is it to get out of the airport
in three minutes, and then wait 45 minutes for a taxi?
The Singapore Airport understands this and has stretched its performance measures
to focus on all the activities associated with the passenger experience - including
ensuring access to cabs. Stretching performance measures is best seen from the
holistic rather than fragmented point of view. It's what will make the
integrated supply chain really integrated, said Lee. The Longitudes counselors
also pointed out that a key way to ensure better customer service is to deliver
complete supply-chain visibility. Visibility, of course, allows companies, customers,
and supply-chain partners to look up and down the supply chain, to see exactly
where an order is, where it's headed, and why.
No one can afford the risk of black holes of information anymore.
On the other hand, a company can greatly enhance customer service by providing
richer, more up-to-date information about shipments in progress. Imagine a service
that would give high-volume shippers detailed visibility into the status of
multiple shipments.
They can share this information electronically with their customers who can
feed it into their own systems like inventory and accounts payable. Visibility
tools like this can help companies provide instant answers to customer questions,
and to do a better job of troubleshooting if something goes wrong.
Differentiating from competitors
When you understand the customer, you can gain a springboard to competitive
advantage, believes Lee. He points to the Spanish apparel manufacturer, Zara,
as a prime example of a firm that uses an holistic supply chain to differentiate
its products in the fast-changing, highly competitive fashion marketplace. Zara
has been growing 20% since the 1990s and the company's net profit margin
is 10%. That compares to an apparel industry average of 3-4%. The apparel maker's
highly flexible, cross-functional supply chain allows it to introduce an incredible
12,000 new products a year. A retail cycle that normally consumes many months,
or even years, has been narrowed by Zara to a single month. Could that produce
retail shortages?
Zara doesn't worry about that because shortages convey an image of scarcity
and hot products. That prompts customers to buy now, and to return often to
see what's new.
In a nutshell, Zara has designed a supply chain that differentiates its products
to match its particular business plan objective - to satisfy customers'
ever-changing appetites for new styles. The fashion manufacturer is willing
to invest in information technology to achieve that alignment objective. That
includes equipping retail store managers with personal digital assistant devices.
The managers continually monitor customer preferences and use the PDAs to electronically
forward data on customer behavior to a central planning office. Design decisions
are made only after incorporating the critical, up-to-the minute customer behavior
data from the stores. The Zara supply chain is all about using the best information
possible to achieve an advantage. Zara's flexibility, pointed out Lee,
also makes it well prepared to adapt quickly when unexpected events occur.
Can manufacturers in other industries achieve similar advantages? What about
an appliance maker? Longitudes panelist Rueben Slone, vice president of supply
chain, North America, for Whirlpool Corporation, put the advantages of product
differentiation this way: "If I can redesign the product, if I can make
it in a smaller plant, if I can make it with smaller parts, If I can ship it
in smaller pieces, if I can get closer to the consumer and change it, I can
change the rules of the game."
Improving cash position
The rules of the game can also be changed to improve cash position, explained
Bob Moffat. In overseeing a US$40 billion dollar supply chain, Moffat's
team has pulled out more than US$7 billion in cost from the IBM supply chain.
Follow the money, advises Moffat, and you'll find a way to improve the
bottom line. Put another way, Victor Fung, chairman of Li & Fung Limited
of Hong Kong, explained that the money to be followed is what he termed, "the
soft US$3."
According to Fung, for every US$1 spent on factory cost, a product is going to
cost US$4 by the time it reaches the customer, or US$5 if it's made in China.
The US$3 or US$4 beyond manufacturing cost amounts to the soft costs associated
with supply chains. They include: overhead, transportation, cost-insurance-and-freight,
duties, in-store delivery and discounts in price due to overstock. Thinking
holistically about the supply chain, he says, affords great opportunity to make
a dent in these soft costs.
To achieve that, one has to look end-to-end, says Fung, "from raw material
to consumer."
If soft costs make up 75% of typical manufacturer- to-consumer supply chains,
no wonder Wall Street likes well-oiled supply chains. An Accenture study found
that from 1995 to 2000 the companies deemed to have the best-run supply chains
had stock-market capitalization rates that were 7-26% above industry averages.
Taking maximum advantage of the capability to synchronize the flow of goods
and information becomes a sure way to maximize cash flow.
Boosting productivity
Of course, increasing productivity is an ongoing C-Level priority. And it's
here that several Longitudes experts believe we've just tapped the surface
when it comes to what supply chains can do. Bob Moffat pointed out that to attain
maximum productivity supply chains must be synchronized outside - as well as
within - the four walls of the company. "I look at parallels outside
the IT industry. I look at the Wal-Mart's and the Proctor & Gamble's.
They understand the supply chain has to expand beyond their four walls. It can
no longer be how efficiently can they do something inside their walls. It's
really, how do they span, how do they make it so their suppliers and retailers
are more productive, so they can get that moment of truth for the customer."
As companies seek out ways to boost productivity, they'll increasingly
focus on their core competencies and leave supply chain design and execution
to partners with the expertise, scale, and resources to get all elements of
the supply chain to operate in unison.
As a group, the Longitudes supply chain experts agreed that the supply chain
had reached a point where it could make a significant difference on each of
the five key universal business challenges.
A common theme that emerged is that the supply chain no longer should exist
independently. In an era of synchronized commerce, it must exist to help the
company achieve its business plan priorities. A clear supply chain strategy
then must flow from, and be tied to, the company's overall business strategy.
As such, the future is going to belong less to how well functional supply chain
silos are managed, and more to how supply chains are designed and led.
"We don't need firemen anymore," concluded Jim Miller, vice
president of manufacturing operations for Cisco Systems, Inc., in describing
the future of supply chain leadership. "We need arsonists."
|